Manchester City found guilty on all Premier League financial charges — expulsion now a live option

Manchester City have been found guilty of all charges related to serious breaches of Premier League financial rules by an independent commission. The club have until Friday to appeal and have indicated they will. Sanctions — including unlimited fines, points deductions, transfer restrictions or expulsion — will be decided at a further confidential hearing.

  • Verdict: Guilty on all charges of serious breaches of Premier League financial rules
  • Appeal deadline: Friday — City have already indicated their intention to appeal
  • Possible sanctions: Unlimited fines, points deductions, transfer restrictions or expulsion from the Premier League
  • Who decides: The independent commission, at a further confidential hearing
  • Relegation route: Only via a points deduction big enough to relegate them from the PL
  • Expulsion route: City would lose PL status and apply to The FA to rejoin the pyramid lower down

Because this case is unprecedented, the commission has very little guidance to work from when handing down punishment. The independent panel does not have the power to relegate City two divisions, or one division. Its only options are expulsion from the Premier League, or a points deduction significant enough to make relegation likely or inevitable.

The panel also cannot make recommendations on where the club might have to re-enter the pyramid. That decision would sit elsewhere — and it is complicated and political.

Who decides the sanctions?

The independent commission decides the sanctions against City. Its options include a fine, a points deduction or even expulsion from the Premier League. The commission cannot demote City by a set number of divisions. It cannot instruct where they play next.

Its two realistic levers are therefore blunt: a points penalty large enough to send City down, or removal from the Premier League altogether. Everything else — the destination, the division, the knock-on effects — falls to other bodies.

How can Manchester City be relegated?

Manchester City can only end up in the Championship if they are given a significant enough points penalty, which means they go on to be relegated from the Premier League. There is no direct route to the second tier via the commission's own powers. Relegation would be a consequence of the points deduction, not a separate sanction.

What happens if Manchester City are expelled from the Premier League?

Expulsion means they are no longer a Premier League club — not that they have been relegated. City would then have to go to The Football Association and apply to rejoin the football pyramid further down.

The problem of re-integration would then lie with The FA and the English Football League. The FA would have a huge part to play in deciding where City play their football next. Where that might be is unknown, and very complicated and political.

One further question the Premier League must decide: whether to negate all of City's results for this season, because the verdict has arrived mid-season. That is an open point the league will have to settle.

How would Manchester City enter the EFL?

Written into the EFL laws: any new member who joins the EFL has to join at League Two. The EFL, like the Premier League, is a collective of its member clubs. Any decision to re-enter City at a certain level — any level from the Championship or below — would have to be ratified by a vote of the member clubs.

If it went to a vote, it would be passed or rejected by a simple majority involving all 72 EFL clubs. That is the system used when the Championship play-offs were expanded from four to six teams last season — it required a majority of the 72 AND a specific majority of the Championship clubs.

The question then becomes whether clubs in any division would be keen for a club of City's power to join their league.

What would happen to the Premier League's missing place?

Expulsion would cause problems in terms of numbers in each competition — leaving only 19 clubs in the Premier League. That will almost certainly mean only two clubs are relegated from the top division that season.

Why the punishment problem is unprecedented

The commission is operating without a precedent. No Premier League club has been expelled, and no points deduction of the scale that would relegate a club of City's stature has ever been handed down. That lack of guidance cuts both ways: it gives the panel freedom, but it also removes any obvious benchmark for City's lawyers to attack on appeal.

Manchester City have indicated they will appeal by Friday's deadline. If that appeal fails, the sanctions hearing becomes the decisive event. The commission cannot split the difference with a mid-range relegation — it can only fine, dock points heavily, or expel. That binary structure is why the points deduction option is so dangerous for City: a penalty small enough to survive would look lenient against a guilty verdict on all charges.

If expulsion follows, the fight shifts from the Premier League to The FA and the EFL. City would need to apply to rejoin lower down, and EFL rules say a new member joins at League Two. Re-entry at Championship level or above would need a vote of all 72 EFL clubs. Clubs in League Two would be weighing a financial windfall against a brutal competitive imbalance. Championship clubs would face the same calculation. The result is a political negotiation as much as a sporting one.

Talking points

  • A points deduction must be big enough to relegate City or it is meaningless — there is no middle sanction available to the commission, which forces a brutal choice.
  • If City are expelled, forcing them to apply to The FA and then face a 72-club EFL vote hands enormous power to rival clubs with obvious self-interest.
  • Negating City's results mid-season would distort the entire table — the Premier League must decide quickly, or the integrity of this campaign is compromised.
  • A 19-club Premier League with only two relegation places changes the economics for every club at the bottom. Nobody has planned for that.

What happens next

Manchester City have until Friday to appeal the judgement, and they have already indicated their intention to do so. If the appeal proceeds, the sanctions decision follows at a further confidential hearing. If City are expelled, The FA and EFL must then decide where they re-enter the pyramid — with a 72-club EFL vote required for any placement from the Championship or below.

Frequently asked questions

Can Manchester City be relegated by the independent commission?

Not directly. The commission cannot relegate City one or two divisions. The only way they end up in the Championship is via a points deduction significant enough to relegate them from the Premier League.

What happens if Manchester City are expelled from the Premier League?

They lose Premier League status and must apply to The FA to rejoin the football pyramid further down. The FA and EFL then handle re-integration, and any entry from the Championship or below needs a vote of all 72 EFL clubs.

Where would Manchester City re-enter the EFL?

EFL laws state any new member joins at League Two. Re-entry at any higher level, including the Championship, would have to be ratified by a simple majority vote of the 72 EFL clubs.

Filed under: Latest News | LA Premier League Home