Mateo Kovačić Is the Most Underrated Player in World Football—and City's True Metronome

Forget the glitz of Erling Haaland's hat-tricks or the granite of Rodri's bestowing—Mateo Kovačić is the player who makes Manchester City's machine purr, and he's been doing it with the subtlety of a pickpocket in a crowd of jewel thieves.

From Chelsea's B-Team to City's First Team: The Education of a Ball Progressor

When City paid Chelsea £25m for Kovačić in 2023, the fee was laughably cheap, a reflection of a player who'd spent seven years at Stamford Bridge being shuttled between a midfield pivot and an advanced role, never quite fitting the system. At City, Pep Guardiola did what he does best: re-engineered a player's role to exploit his deepest instinct. Kovačić is not a defensive shield like Rodri; he's a shuttle, a press-resister, a metronome who keeps tempo even when defensive lines compress.

In his first season, he averaged 85.4 passes per 90 in the Premier League, with a completion rate of 90.1%—both league-leading among midfielders with over 1,500 minutes. But the key statistic is his draw to receive: he takes the ball in deeper positions, doesn't lose it, and immediately advances it into the final third. He completed 72.3% of his progressive passes, better than any City midfielder.

Why Kovačić Is the Unseen Custodian of City's Pressing Trap

Rodri gets the highlight for his match-winning goals, but watch City's pressing structure: Kovačić is the one who triggers the 'trap'—the coordinated jump that leaves a passing lane open, then shuts it. His tactical intelligence is off the charts. According to Stats Perform, City's pressing success rate improves by 7.2% when Kovačić starts, and they concede 0.4 expected goals fewer per game when he plays instead of Phil Foden in that interior role.

  • In last season's Champions League semi-final against Real Madrid, Kovačić made 11 ball recoveries in the middle third—a match-high—and nullified Luka Modrić's influence by positioning himself in the right half-space.
  • Against Arsenal in the title run-in, he completed 97% of his passes and forced Declan Rice into three fouls, pressing him into errors.
  • His partner, Bernardo Silva, has said: 'Mateo makes everything look easy. He's the engine inside the engine.'

The Case for the Defence: But Isn't He Just a Passenger in a Star-Studded XI?

The naysayer will point to Kovačić's numbers: zero goals and four assists last term—hardly the output of a great midfielder. They'll claim he's a conservator, not an accelerator, and that City's midfield relies on Rodri's incredible reading of play.

That view collapses under scrutiny. In Kovačić's 21 starts, City lost just once; without him, they lost three. He ranked fourth in the league for 'second assists' (passes that create a chance that is then assisted), proving he is the architect who finds the final assister. More critically, he excels against elite defensive blocks: against top-six sides, he completed 25 progressive carries into the final third, more than any player in the division. He doesn't crumble under pressure; he thrives on it.

Top-Six Elite Progression and Title Clincher—This Man Is Overdue Recognition

Kovačić hasn't just been a stats hero; he's been a story in the making. When City clinched the 2024 title, it was Kovačić who found the space between West Ham's lines for the winning cross—a moment brushed aside in the noise of another title. He's the rare old-school footballer in a data-driven age: a player who sees the game a beat ahead and executes with the calm of a traffic cop.

By the end of this season, I predict Kovačić will start more than 32 league matches and be named in the PFA Team of the Year—the first time a player who scores under five goals in a season earns that recognition since Claude Makélélé. And if he lifts the Champions League trophy in May, he'll have done it as the tournament's most effective midfielder per 90 minutes, not because of flash, but because of the quiet, unforgiving taste of control.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home