Everton Are Not Fixed — They Are Hiding in Plain Sight

Sean Dyche has performed a miracle at Goodison Park, dragging a club on life support to Premier League safety two seasons running. But miracles do not last. The reported interest in Newcastle’s Jacob Murphy — a winger with four league goals in two seasons — is not a stopgap. It is a confession. Everton’s attack is not merely underperforming; it is structurally broken, and Murphy would be a bandage on a bullet wound.

The Midfield Abyss That Starves Forwards

Dyche’s Everton have conceded just 1.2 goals per game defensively, a respectable mid-table figure. Offensively, they average 1.0 goals per game — 15th in the league. But the rot lies deeper: Everton rank 19th in progressive passes per 90 and 18th in passes into the penalty area. Their midfield trio — often Idrissa Gueye, James Garner, and Abdoulaye Doucouré — creates almost nothing. Gueye is a defensive shield, Garner a recycling metronome, and Doucouré a late runner who needs service he rarely receives.

Compare this to a functioning mid-table side like Crystal Palace under Oliver Glasner, whose midfielders Eberechi Eze and Adam Wharton average 3.2 key passes per game combined. Everton’s entire midfield averages 1.9. The consequence: Dominic Calvert-Lewin, a striker who thrives on crosses and through balls, receives just 2.1 touches in the opposition box per game — fewer than Nottingham Forest’s Chris Wood (3.4) and Brentford’s Yoane Wissa (4.0).

Why Jacob Murphy Is a Symptom, Not a Solution

Murphy is a hard-working, direct winger — but he is not a creator. In the last two seasons at Newcastle, he has registered 0.9 key passes per 90 and created 2 big chances total. For context, Everton’s current widemen — Dwight McNeil (1.5 key passes per 90) and Jack Harrison (1.1) — already offer as much or more. The pursuit of Murphy signals that Dyche and the recruitment team believe the problem is personnel, not system. That is a dangerous delusion.

  • Crossing volume over quality: Everton rank 5th in crosses per game (21.3) but 18th in crossing accuracy (24%). Murphy crosses 3.1 times per 90 with 26% accuracy — more of the same.
  • Dribbling inefficiency: Murphy completes 0.8 dribbles per 90, similar to Harrison (0.7). Neither beats defenders consistently to unbalance defences.
  • End product: In 89 Premier League appearances for Newcastle, Murphy has 7 goals and 3 assists. Over 38 games, that’s 3 goals and 1 assist. Not a game-changer.

The real issue is that Everton’s attacking patterns are predictable and slow. Dyche encourages early crosses from deep, but Calvert-Lewin is often outnumbered by two centre-backs. The lack of a creative midfielder means no reverse passes or through balls. Adding Murphy is like hiring a faster postman when the mail system is broken.

The Counter-Argument: Dyche’s Style Worked Before

Defenders of Dyche will point to Burnley’s 2017-18 season, when Ashley Barnes and Chris Wood scored 19 goals combined from wide crosses. They will argue that Everton’s defence is too fragile to risk a more open midfield. Fair points — but the Premier League has evolved. The top teams now press in packs and suffocate crossing lanes. Everton’s crossing is no longer a weapon; it is a turnover machine. Since the start of last season, only Sheffield United have lost possession more times from crosses than Everton (287).

Moreover, Burnley’s midfield featured Steven Defour and Jack Cork — passers who could switch play and stretch defences. Everton’s current midfield lacks that range. Gueye’s pass completion is 84%, but he rarely plays forward; Garner’s long passing is average; Doucouré’s first touch often kills attacks. Without a technical upgrade in central areas, no winger — not even a prime Eden Hazard — would thrive.

The Only Cure Is Structural Change

Everton must stop buying square pegs and start rethinking the shape of the hole. They need a midfield creator — a player who can receive between the lines and play line-breaking passes. The links to Jacob Murphy suggest a continued reliance on wing play, which will only deepen the rut. A specific, falsifiable prediction: if Everton sign Murphy and do not sign a creative midfielder in the same window, they will finish 17th or lower next season, with Calvert-Lewin scoring fewer than 10 league goals. The cancer is in the midfield, and Murphy is no cure.

Filed under: Tactical Analysis | LA Premier League Home