Forget the headline names—City's real engine is hiding in plain sight

Matheus Nunes is the Premier League's most underrated player. While pundits drool over Foden, Haaland, and Rodri, Nunes has morphed into Pep Guardiola's Swiss Army knife, silencing opponents and critics alike with relentless, intelligent football. And yet, he barely gets a mention.

From Wolves misfit to City's metronome

When Nunes joined Wolves from Sporting CP in 2022, he was a £38m enigma: flashes of brilliance, but inconsistent. A year later, City paid £53m for him, and many scoffed. He was seen as a squad filler, a project. But Guardiola doesn't buy projects—he buys solutions.

Recall the 2023/24 season: Nunes started only 14 league games but averaged 2.3 tackles and 1.8 key passes per 90, per FBref. In the Champions League, his pressing resistance and carry metrics were elite. He wasn't a regular, but he was a vital rotation piece. This season, with injuries to De Bruyne and Rodri's occasional absences, Nunes has stepped up. In his last five starts, City have conceded just twice, and his pass completion sits at 91%. He's not just filling gaps; he's redefining them.

The case for Nunes as City's most complete midfielder

Nunes does the dirty work and the pretty work. He's a defensive screen, a progressive carrier, and a late-arriving goal threat. His versatility allows Guardiola to switch between 4-3-3 and 3-2-4-1 mid-game without losing control. Here's why he's indispensable:

  • Defensive solidity: He ranks in the top 5% of Premier League midfielders for interceptions per 90 (1.9), often snuffing out counters before they start.
  • Ball progression: His 6.2 progressive carries per 90 are better than Rodri's (5.8) and comparable to Bernardo Silva's, easing the build-up burden.
  • Tactical discipline: Against Arsenal in September, he nullified Odegaard's space, making four tackles and completing 94% of his passes in a 1-0 win.

These aren't flashy numbers, but they're the glue. City's machine runs on precision, and Nunes provides it without fanfare.

The counter-argument: he's a system player, not a star

Detractors argue Nunes benefits from City's galaxy of talent—that any competent midfielder would thrive. They point to his lack of goals (just 3 in 45 league games) and occasional rash challenges. But that misses the point. City's system relies on players who can adapt on the fly, and Nunes does so more seamlessly than Kalvin Phillips ever did. His goal tally is low because his role is rotational; when he does shoot, his xG per shot (0.14) is higher than Kovacic's. He's not a passenger; he's a facilitator. And in big games—like the 2-1 win over Liverpool last month—he was City's highest-rated player (WhoScored 8.1), dictating tempo and breaking lines.

Prediction: Nunes will be City's Player of the Season dark horse

By May 2026, Matheus Nunes will have started at least 25 Premier League games for Manchester City and will be shortlisted for the club's Player of the Season award. If he stays fit, City will retain the title, and Nunes will finally get the recognition he deserves—or not, because football's obsession with goals and assists will continue to obscure the truth. But mark this: his name will be on the lips of every sporting director in Europe, and City will reject bids north of £70m. The invisible fixer won't stay invisible for long.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home