The invisibility of the essential

Mateo Kovacic has started 14 Premier League games for Manchester City this season. Nobody noticed. Which is precisely why he might be the most underappreciated footballer in the division. In a league obsessed with goals, assists, and the kind of gaudy metrics that light up Fantasy Football algorithms, Kovacic does the one thing that cannot be measured: he makes everyone around him better without ever demanding credit.

From Chelsea cast-off to silent spine

When City paid Chelsea £30m for Kovacic in 2023, the consensus was that they had acquired a reliable squad player. Someone to rotate with Kevin De Bruyne, not replace him. Eighteen months on, the narrative has flipped. De Bruyne, now 33 and increasingly brittle, has missed 12 league matches this season through injury. City have not collapsed. The reason is Kovacic.

His numbers are unremarkable: two goals, three assists. But his pass completion rate of 93.7% ranks second among midfielders with more than 1,000 minutes. More tellingly, City average 2.3 points per game with Kovacic starting, compared to 1.9 when he doesn't. The difference is subtle but structural. Kovacic is the ballast that allows Rodri to roam, the safety valve that lets Phil Foden take risks, the quiet intelligence that sustains Guardiola's machine when others break down.

The art of keeping the ball moving

Kovacic's genius is not in the spectacular but in the prophylactic. He receives the ball under pressure and, with a single turn, removes the danger. His dribbling success rate of 84% is the highest of any City midfielder. He does not seek the killer pass; he seeks the correct pass. The one that maintains tempo, resets the shape, suffocates the opposition's pressing triggers. It is an art form that the Premier League's analytics industry has yet to quantify.

Consider the following examples from this season:

  • Against Arsenal in October, Kovacic completed 48 of 49 passes in a 2-1 win. His one misplaced pass came from a headed clearance. Arsenal's press, which had suffocated Spurs and Liverpool, foundered on Kovacic's ability to receive on the half-turn and release before contact.
  • In the 2-0 victory over Nottingham Forest, Kovacic made six progressive carries from deep positions, each one forcing Forest's midfield to retreat. Not a single one led directly to a goal. But combined, they pinned Forest in their own half for 70% of the match.
  • Away at Newcastle, Kovacic produced seven ball recoveries and completed all 12 of his attempted passes under pressure. City won 3-1. The match report led with Haaland's brace. Not a single analysis piece mentioned Kovacic. That is the point.

But he doesn't score, he doesn't assist

The counter-argument writes itself: Kovacic is a water carrier in an era of all-action midfielders. Jude Bellingham scores, Declan Rice dictates, Rodri drills in worldies from 25 yards. Kovacic does none of these things. His goal contribution per 90 is 0.12, the lowest of any regular City midfielder. If his value is purely defensive, why not play a second holding player?

The reductiveness of that thinking is precisely what the Premier League's transfer market has come to reward. Clubs like Manchester United — reportedly planning a £100m move for Felix Nmecha — chase the headline name, the player who fits a scouting report of height, power and goal threat. Meanwhile, the Kovacics of this world are undervalued, underpaid, and underestimated. Nmecha's pass completion this season: 82.1%. Kovacic's: 93.7%. The difference is efficiency. The difference is intelligence. The difference is why one player costs £100m and the other was deemed surplus to requirements at Chelsea.

What Kovacic offers is not flash but fundament. He is the connective tissue that makes City's press resistant. Without him, Guardiola's side becomes more predictable, more reliant on individual brilliance. With him, they become a machine that cannot be burgled. His awareness of space, his ability to receive in tight areas, his composure under duress — these are the attributes that allow elite football to function at its highest level. They are also the attributes that are systematically ignored by a transfer industry that trades in highlight reels.

Why City must build around him now

Kovacic turns 31 in May. His contract runs until 2026, but there should be no debate about an extension. With De Bruyne's decline imminent and Bernardo Silva's future uncertain, Kovacic is not a stopgap. He is the bridge. Guardiola's system demands at least one midfielder who can beat a press through dribbling and short passing. Kovacic is that player. Losing him would force a tactical overhaul that City cannot afford during a period of transition.

My prediction is specific: Kovacic will start the Champions League final if City reach it. He will not score. He will not provide an assist. But he will be the player Guardiola refuses to drop. And after the match, the mainstream media will give man of the match to Haaland or Foden. That will be the truest testament to Kovacic's greatness — that he wins the biggest games without anyone ever quite understanding why.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home