Maresca: Foden and Fernandes Should Have Seen Red in Manchester Derby

Enzo Maresca believes both Phil Foden and Bruno Fernandes should have been sent off in Manchester City's derby victory against Manchester United. The Manchester City manager made the claim after his side's 1-0 win at Old Trafford, a result that keeps City's Premier League title challenge on track and deepens United's problems.

  • Competition: Premier League
  • Fixture: Manchester United vs Manchester City
  • Result: Manchester United 0-1 Manchester City
  • Key claim: Enzo Maresca says Phil Foden and Bruno Fernandes should have been sent off
  • Manager: Enzo Maresca
  • Published: 15 hours ago

What was said

"Fernandes and Foden should have been sent off"

— Enzo Maresca, on the Manchester derby officiating

Maresca's post-match assessment put the spotlight squarely on the referee's handling of two flashpoints involving Phil Foden and Bruno Fernandes. By naming both players, the City manager avoided singling out one club and instead framed his complaint as a consistency issue across the 90 minutes.

The timing is significant. City had just secured a 1-0 win at Old Trafford, and Maresca's comments ensured the conversation shifted from the result to the officiating. For United, the defeat leaves them with nothing from the derby, and the Fernandes element adds another layer to a difficult afternoon.

Why Maresca's comments matter after the Old Trafford win

Maresca is not a manager who routinely picks fights with referees, so the decision to name both Phil Foden and Bruno Fernandes carries weight. The City boss is protecting his players while also signalling that he felt the threshold for a red card was met twice. That is a deliberate choice: it shifts scrutiny onto the officials rather than onto City's performance.

From a tactical standpoint, Foden's involvement in the derby was always going to be central to how City attacked. If Maresca felt Foden was fortunate to stay on, it suggests the game was played close to the edge in midfield areas. For United, Fernandes is the emotional and creative hub, and any suggestion he should have walked will be contested fiercely by the Old Trafford faithful.

The broader context is the ongoing debate about consistency in Premier League officiating. Maresca's claim will be measured against other incidents from the same weekend, and refereeing body PGMOL is unlikely to comment publicly on a manager's interpretation. What is clear is that City took the three points, and Maresca wants the narrative to include his view on the discipline question.

Talking points

  • Should Maresca have named both Foden and Fernandes, or does that weaken his argument by making it sound like a general grievance rather than a specific injustice?
  • If Fernandes had been sent off, would Manchester United have been able to hold City to 0-0, or would the extra space have made it easier for the visitors?
  • Does Maresca's willingness to criticise referees after a win suggest he is already thinking about future decisions going City's way in tight matches?
  • How will United's supporters react to their captain being linked with a red card in a derby defeat?

What happens next

Manchester City return to Premier League action with the three points from Old Trafford secured, while Manchester United must regroup from a 0-1 home defeat. Maresca's comments will be assessed by the football authorities in the coming days, though no disciplinary action against either player was confirmed in the source. The next round of fixtures will test whether the officiating debate follows both clubs.

Frequently asked questions

Who did Enzo Maresca say should have been sent off in the Manchester derby?

Maresca said both Phil Foden and Bruno Fernandes should have been sent off in Manchester City's derby victory against Manchester United.

What was the score in Manchester United vs Manchester City?

Manchester City won 1-0 against Manchester United, according to the source article.

Which competition was the Manchester derby played in?

The match was a Premier League fixture between Manchester United and Manchester City.

Filed under: Manager News | LA Premier League Home