Manchester United line up Hurzeler, Nagelsmann and Conte as Carrick pressure builds before Leeds trip
Manchester United are actively considering managerial alternatives to Michael Carrick, with Fabian Hurzeler, Julian Nagelsmann and Antonio Conte reportedly on a shortlist if results do not improve. Pressure is mounting ahead of Sunday's Premier League trip to Leeds, following a five-match winless run and the club's worst start to a top-flight season in 40 years.
- Fixture: Leeds United vs Manchester United, Sunday, Elland Road, Premier League
- Context: United are without a win in five matches in all competitions, including a 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid on Tuesday
- Pressure: talkSPORT reports Fabian Hurzeler, Julian Nagelsmann and Antonio Conte are on a shortlist should Michael Carrick lose his job
- Availability: Nagelsmann and Conte are available immediately; Hurzeler is under contract at Brighton until 2029
- Internal support: Christopher Vivell is pushing for Nagelsmann; Jason Wilcox is thought to favour Hurzeler
- At stake: Another defeat at Elland Road could force Manchester United to move from contingency planning to action
What was said
"Does it feel like an inevitability? Absolutely, that Michael Carrick will go."
"It feels like it's something that he can't stop unless they turn around those results."
"You've got to look at the players, absolutely. And you have to ask the question, is Michael Carrick going to be good enough to manage Manchester United? Let's analyse that, because he made some changes yesterday, tactically, that absolutely baffled and floored me and they proved to be their undoing."
"Elland Road will be fierce on Sunday, Leeds hate Manchester United. They would love nothing more at Elland Road to put that dagger in. I think that Leeds could do a number on Manchester United."
Durham's verdict reflects a growing sense that Carrick's position is becoming untenable. His tactical changes against Atletico Madrid drew particular criticism, with Durham describing them as baffling and ultimately costly. The comments also hint at broader concerns about United's direction and the manager's ability to reverse the slump.
The numbers
- 5 — Matches without a win for Manchester United in all competitions
- 2-0 — Defeat to Atletico Madrid on Tuesday night
- 1-1 — Draw with Spurs during the winless run
- 40 years — United's worst start to a Premier League season in four decades
- 3 — Names on the shortlist should Carrick lose his job: Fabian Hurzeler, Julian Nagelsmann, Antonio Conte
- 2029 — Year Hurzeler's Brighton contract runs until
- 3rd — Brighton's current Premier League position after four wins from six matches
Why Hurzeler, Nagelsmann and Conte all carry different risks
Manchester United's reported shortlist is not a simple queue of names — each candidate brings a distinct profile. Julian Nagelsmann and Antonio Conte are available immediately, which matters if the club decides to act quickly after the Leeds match. Nagelsmann has internal backing from Christopher Vivell, suggesting a desire for a modern, ambitious appointment. Conte offers pedigree and a demand for immediate standards, but also intensity and short-term pressure.
Fabian Hurzeler is the most complicated option. He is under contract at Brighton until 2029, and the Seagulls sit third in the Premier League after four wins from six matches. He has already shown he can hurt United, having overseen the comeback that knocked them out of the EFL Cup in September. Any move for him would be far from straightforward, but his work has naturally attracted attention. Jason Wilcox is thought to favour Hurzeler, which adds an internal dynamic to the decision.
On the pitch, United's immediate concern is Sunday at Elland Road. Carrick's tactical choices against Atletico came under the spotlight, and another setback would intensify calls for change. The atmosphere is expected to be unforgiving, and there is little room for a soft landing in a rivalry of this scale. If results dictate timing, this weekend could become the moment when United's manager search moves from contingency planning to action.
Talking points
- Adrian Durham calls Carrick's departure an "inevitability" — but is it fair to judge him on a five-match winless run that includes tough fixtures?
- Julian Nagelsmann has internal backing from Christopher Vivell, but would his appointment require a major squad overhaul in January?
- Fabian Hurzeler is under contract at Brighton until 2029 and the Seagulls sit third — can United realistically prise him away mid-season?
- Lisandro Martinez criticised Jason Wilcox for a lack of squad strengthening — does that undermine the technical director's authority in any managerial search?
What happens next
Manchester United travel to Elland Road on Sunday to face Leeds in the Premier League. A defeat could force the club to accelerate their managerial contingency plans, with Nagelsmann and Conte available immediately and Hurzeler admired internally. The result is expected to shape the next decision at Old Trafford.
Frequently asked questions
Is Michael Carrick under pressure at Manchester United?
Yes. United are without a win in five matches in all competitions and have made their worst start to a Premier League season in 40 years, with talkSPORT reporting that Carrick could lose his job if results do not improve.
Who could replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United?
Fabian Hurzeler, Julian Nagelsmann and Antonio Conte are the three names on a shortlist should Carrick lose his job, according to talkSPORT. Nagelsmann and Conte are available immediately, while Hurzeler is under contract at Brighton until 2029.
What happened in Manchester United's last match?
United lost 2-0 to Atletico Madrid on Tuesday night, extending their winless run to five matches in all competitions. That sequence also included a 1-1 draw with Spurs.
Related Articles
Filed under: Manager News | LA Premier League Home
