Manchester City's Guilty Verdict Is Not a Victory for FFP — It's Proof the System Is Broken

Manchester City were found guilty of over 100 financial rule breaches, yet the real scandal is that FFP still allows clubs to profit from cheating. The verdict exposes a system designed to protect the powerful, not punish them.

FFP: A History of Protecting the Wrong People

Financial Fair Play was introduced in 2011 to stop clubs spending beyond their means. In practice, it has become a tool for established elite clubs to pull up the drawbridge. Manchester City, backed by Abu Dhabi wealth, challenged that order. But their guilt does not make FFP just. It merely reveals its hypocrisy.

Consider the numbers. City were found to have inflated sponsorship deals by £830.69m between 2009 and 2018. That is not a minor accounting error; it is industrial-scale deception. Yet the punishment — likely a points deduction or expulsion — will be fought in the courts for years. Meanwhile, the Premier League's own rules allow clubs to write off stadium investment, and owners can convert debt to equity. The game is rigged, but not in the way City's defenders claim.

The Guilty Verdict Is a Failure of Governance, Not Justice

The independent commission's ruling that City breached rules on sponsorships and 'sham' deals is damning. But the fact that it took a decade to reach this point, and that City knew of the verdict before their summer spending spree, shows a governance vacuum. The Premier League allowed a club to spend heavily while knowing it had been found guilty. That is not justice; it is negligence.

City's appeal, due by Friday, will argue the verdict is 'unsafe'. They may have a point — not on the facts, but on the process. The Premier League has been slow, leaky, and inconsistent. Everton and Nottingham Forest were punished swiftly for minor breaches; City's industrial-scale fraud has taken years. The disparity is not a coincidence; it is a feature of a system that fears the powerful.

  • Everton were deducted 10 points (reduced to 6 on appeal) for a single breach of profitability rules, while City face a possible points deduction for 115 breaches.
  • Nottingham Forest were docked 4 points for a minor overspend, yet City's £830m sponsorship fraud has taken over a decade to adjudicate.
  • UEFA's original case against City was time-barred, forcing the Premier League to act — a clear sign that authorities only pursue when forced.

The Counter-Argument: City Are Victims of a Cartel

City's defence is that FFP is a cartel designed to keep new money out. There is truth here. The rules were drafted by the old elite — Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool — to protect their commercial dominance. But City's response was not to challenge the rules democratically; it was to break them systematically. They lied about sponsorships, hid payments, and misled authorities. That is not rebellion; it is fraud.

Moreover, City's own financial might, built on inflated deals, has distorted the transfer market for everyone. Their £100m signings, funded by sham sponsorships, have driven up prices and wages, harming smaller clubs. City are not victims; they are architects of the very distortion they decry.

The Verdict Will Change Nothing Unless Punishment Fits the Crime

If City receive a points deduction that still allows them to qualify for Europe, or a fine that is a rounding error on their balance sheet, the message is clear: cheat, and you will prosper. The only just outcome is relegation or expulsion, and the stripping of titles won during the breach period. Anything less is an admission that the Premier League is incapable of governing itself.

Prediction: Manchester City will avoid relegation and will be playing Premier League football in 2026-27, but they will be stripped of at least two Premier League titles from the 2011-12 to 2017-18 period. The Premier League will announce a points deduction that is suspended on appeal, rendering it meaningless. The real losers will be the fans of every other club, who will watch the rich get richer while the rules are rewritten to protect them.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home