Manchester City's youth project is dead. Long live the cheque book.

Pep Guardiola's side are on the verge of spending £100m on a teenager from PSV, Ayyoub Bouaddi, a player who has played precisely 34 senior games. This is not ambition. It is an admission.

The academy that became a myth

City's youth setup was supposed to be the envy of Europe. From Sancho to Foden, Lavia to Palmer, the production line churned out talent. But the club's strategy has shifted. They sold Cole Palmer for £42.5m and bought Jérémy Doku for £55m. They let James McAtee rot on the bench. Now, instead of giving minutes to their own, they are prepared to break the bank for a Dutch teenager.

The numbers tell the story. Since 2020, City have made over £200m from academy sales: Sancho, Brahim Díaz, Lavia, Palmer, Rogers. Yet only Phil Foden and Rico Lewis have become first-team regulars. The rest were traded for profit. The Bouaddi deal is a final rejection of the club's own production line.

The argument: Paying for promise is a sick bet

  • Ayyoub Bouaddi has 34 senior appearances. The £100m fee equals more per game than most strikers cost per goal.
  • City's own academy has produced players of similar profile — Oscar Bobb, Micah Hamilton — but they are either loaned out or sold.
  • This is a pattern: in 2023, they spent £100m on Raphinha (Barcelona) and £80m on Doku. Both are wide attackers, an area where their own youth could have been developed.

The argument that Bouaddi is a generational talent ignores the club's track record. When they bought Haaland, they got a proven machine. When they bought Grealish, they got a proven creator. Bouaddi is a projection — and projections are what you sell to other clubs, not what you buy for yourself.

The rebuttal: What about the success stories?

You will hear the counter: City's academy is a success because it funds the first team. That deals for Alajbegovic and Bouaddi are the new model. This is sophistry. Buying raw teenagers is the opposite of an academy philosophy. You either trust your scouting and coaching to produce players, or you outsource it. City have chosen the latter.

The £35m deal for Kerim Alajbegovic from Bayer Leverkusen, agreed last week, reinforces the point. That player is 18, with 12 senior appearances. City are hoarding potential from abroad while their own Carrington graduates move to Southampton and Brighton. That is not a strategy. It is a tax on a reputational asset.

Verdict: City will regret this before 2028

By the time Bouaddi turns 24, City will have spent over £150m on his wages and amortisation. He will be their fourth-choice winger, while at least two of their current academy stars will be starting for Champions League rivals. The club's decision to prioritise speculative foreign talent over homegrown depth is a mistake that the fixture list will expose. Expect Oscar Bobb to be sold for £50m within two years, and City to again lament a lack of homegrown identity.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home