James McAtee's Nottingham Forest struggle: What next amid Elliot Anderson uncertainty

James McAtee faces uncertain future after difficult Forest spell

James McAtee's loan spell at Nottingham Forest last season did not go as planned. The Manchester City academy graduate managed only limited appearances, failing to establish himself in Steve Cooper's side. Now, with Elliot Anderson reportedly a target for City, questions surround McAtee's next move.

McAtee's season in numbers: Limited impact at the City Ground

During the 2023/24 campaign, McAtee featured in just 11 Premier League matches for Forest, accumulating a mere 267 minutes of playing time. He contributed one assist but failed to score. The 21-year-old's average of 24 minutes per appearance suggests he was never fully trusted in the starting XI. Forest's survival battle meant Cooper often favoured experienced heads over youthful experimentation.

McAtee's playing time was concentrated in cup competitions and cameo league roles. His only start in the Premier League came in a 3-1 defeat to Brighton in April, where he played 69 minutes. That match highlighted both his promise and rawness—he completed 87% of his passes but registered zero shots or key passes.

Tactical fit: Why McAtee struggled at Forest

Forest's system under Cooper was built on defensive solidity and counter-attacking speed. They often deployed a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 formation that demanded disciplined midfield work. McAtee, primarily an attacking midfielder or winger, found himself competing with more physical, defensive-minded players like Ryan Yates and Danilo. His slight frame and preference for creative, central areas did not align with Forest's need for gritty midfielders who could protect the backline.

At Manchester City, McAtee is seen as a potential successor to Kevin De Bruyne's creative mantle. However, his development requires regular minutes in a possession-based system—something Pep Guardiola could offer if he stays, but unlikely given City's stacked squad. If Anderson departs for the Etihad, it may open a pathway for McAtee at Nottingham Forest or elsewhere.

The Elliot Anderson factor: How it impacts McAtee

Elliot Anderson, a versatile Newcastle midfielder, has been linked with a move to Manchester City this summer. The Athletic reported that City are considering a bid of around £30 million for the 21-year-old. Should that transfer materialise, Forest—who had Anderson on loan in 2022/23—might re-enter the race for McAtee. However, given McAtee's underwhelming spell, Forest may be cautious about revisiting that deal.

Alternatively, McAtee could be used as a makeweight in a deal for Anderson. City value McAtee highly, but his lack of first-team experience reduces his market value. A loan or permanent sale could be on the cards if Guardiola decides the youngster needs another season away.

What next for McAtee? Three possible outcomes

Another Championship loan: After failing in the Premier League, a step down to the Championship could rebuild McAtee's confidence. A club like Sheffield United or Middlesbrough, who play possession football, could be ideal.
Premier League loan to a lower-half side: Clubs like Burnley or Luton Town—who need creative midfielders—might take a punt on McAtee's technical ability. However, they would demand guarantees of playing time.
Manchester City squad integration: If City fail to sign Anderson, McAtee could stay as a domestic cup specialist. But with Phil Foden, Bernardo Silva, and Cole Palmer ahead of him, minutes would be scarce.

Fantasy Premier League context: McAtee remains a punt only

In FPL, McAtee is priced at £4.5 million—the minimum for midfielders. He was owned by just 0.2% of managers last season. If he secures a loan move to a club where he is a guaranteed starter, his price could rise. However, until a move is confirmed, he remains a deep budget option with no guaranteed minutes. FPL managers should avoid him unless he becomes a regular starter in a favourable system.

Conclusion: McAtee's career at a crossroads

James McAtee is a classic example of a talented youngster stuck between a top-tier club's demanding standards and a lower-tier club's lack of patience. The Anderson- City link adds a layer of complexity to his future. Whether he stays at City, returns to Forest, or moves elsewhere, the next step will define his career trajectory. A successful loan spell at a club that prioritises technical play could resurrect his path to stardom. For now, McAtee waits—and the football world watches closely.