Fulham vs Manchester United: Arbeloa and Carrick Under Pressure
Fulham host Manchester United at Craven Cottage on Sunday in the final fixture before the three-week international break, with both Alvaro Arbeloa and Michael Carrick under scrutiny after difficult starts. Arbeloa has no wins and three defeats from four Premier League matches; Carrick's United lost 3-2 to Brighton in the EFL Cup on Wednesday.
- Fixture: Fulham vs Manchester United, Craven Cottage
- Competition: Premier League
- Date: Sunday, final match before the three-week international break
- Fulham form: No wins from four Premier League games, bottom of the table with one point
- United form: 3-2 EFL Cup exit to Brighton, 1-0 loss to 10-man Manchester City; wins only against Ipswich Town and Sabah
- At stake: Both managers face intense scrutiny during the extended break
Why the three-week break raises the stakes
The September international break is longer than usual — three weeks rather than two — and arrives later in the calendar. Historically, Premier League clubs rarely change managers at this point. Over the past 10 years, only two top-flight bosses have departed during the September break: Watford's Javi Gracia in 2019 and Nottingham Forest's Nuno Espirito Santo last year.
The October stoppage has produced just two managerial changes in a decade: Francesco Guidolin at Swansea in 2016 and Xisco Munoz at Watford in 2021. November is far more volatile, with six managers replaced in the past 10 years. Nine coaches had left their jobs by the time the second international break arrived across the last 10 campaigns — which is the equivalent stage in terms of matches played.
Former Stoke, West Brom and Middlesbrough boss Tony Pulis believes the pause gives struggling clubs a chance to bed in a new manager. "The October/November international breaks, the pause just after the Christmas period, and then early March would be the three sticking points," he said. Pulis added that "those international breaks... definitely heighten the chances of struggling managers getting the sack" but does not see this September break as a trigger, calling it "too early in the season".
Manager-by-manager: who is feeling the heat
Manchester United — Michael Carrick
Carrick's position is not viewed as make-or-break at Fulham, but the manner of recent defeats has intensified debate. United led 2-0 at home before losing 3-2 to Brighton in the EFL Cup on Wednesday — the first time they had lost at home after leading by two goals since a 3-2 defeat to Tottenham in 1976. That followed a 1-0 loss to 10-man Manchester City. Their only victories this season came against Ipswich Town and Sabah.
Carrick said it would be "ridiculous" to think the trip to Craven Cottage could decide his future. He retains credit from steering United into the Champions League last season. However, a first defeat at Fulham since 2009 — against a team with one point and bottom of the table — would generate external inquests before United resume against Tottenham on 10 October.
Fulham — Alvaro Arbeloa
Arbeloa was appointed in the summer after taking charge of just 28 games as Real Madrid boss in the second half of last season. He has no wins and three defeats in his opening four Premier League matches. Reports of disgruntlement among elements of the squad have some substance, and his significant tactical changes since replacing Marco Silva have left Fulham vulnerable at the back. They did produce a more solid display in a goalless draw away to Liverpool last weekend.
Owner Shahid Khan has previously shown a ruthless streak: Claudio Ranieri lasted just 106 days, while Felix Magath was sacked in September 2014.
Tottenham — Roberto de Zerbi
Despite spending about £300m on new talent in the summer, Tottenham have no wins from six games. There is no sense that De Zerbi is under pressure, with positive vibes around the team's style of play and a belief that it is only a matter of time before results click.
Crystal Palace — Pierre Sage
Pierre Sage has endured an indifferent start, with one league win and a leaky defence since arriving from Lens. Allowances are being made for the absence of key attackers Ismaila Sarr and Jean-Philippe Mateta. A 4-0 Europa League win over Lech Poznan on Thursday eased some pressure, but a defeat at Leeds this afternoon would compound matters.
Burnley — Nicky Hayen
Hayen quit Genk to spearhead Burnley's bid for an immediate Premier League return. The Clarets started as third favourites for promotion behind West Ham and Wolves, but are winless in eight matches. Hayen admitted he was under pressure before Saturday's must-win game against Derby, which ended in a disappointing 1-1 draw after a stoppage-time equaliser. Burnley go into the break bottom of the table, and the board may now be assessing their options.
The numbers
- September international break managerial changes (past 10 years): 2 — Javi Gracia (Watford, 2019) and Nuno Espirito Santo (Nottingham Forest, 2024)
- October international break changes (past 10 years): 2 — Francesco Guidolin (Swansea, 2016) and Xisco Munoz (Watford, 2021)
- November changes (past 10 years): 6
- Managers gone by second international break (past 10 campaigns): 9
- Sacked this season: Paul Heckingbottom (Preston North End), Michael Duff (Wycombe Wanderers)
- Tottenham summer spend: about £300m
- Burnley league position: bottom, winless in eight
What was said
"The October/November international breaks, the pause just after the Christmas period, and then early March would be the three sticking points for any manager who was struggling with results."
"Those international breaks, for the reasons I've given, definitely heighten the chances of struggling managers getting the sack."
"I don't see this September break as a flashing light, it is too early in the season."
"But this early international break doesn't help any managers. Whether your team is winning or losing, on both accounts, it's a nightmare."
Pulis's view is a clear-eyed assessment of how boardrooms operate. Clubs weighing a change prefer the cushion of a two-week reset to install a new manager, allow him to assess staff and players, and prepare for a first fixture — often an FA Cup tie after Christmas. A three-week break offers even more room for that process, which is precisely why a heavy defeat on Sunday could accelerate decisions at Fulham or United.
What happens next
Fulham and Manchester United meet at Craven Cottage on Sunday. United then face Tottenham on 10 October; Fulham will also resume after the break. Burnley go into the pause bottom of the table after their 1-1 draw with Derby, and the board may now be assessing their position. Crystal Palace's trip to Leeds this afternoon could shape Pierre Sage's immediate future.
Frequently asked questions
Is Fulham vs Manchester United the last game before the international break?
Yes. The match at Craven Cottage on Sunday is the final Premier League fixture before the three-week international break.
How many Premier League managers have been sacked during the September international break?
Only two in the past 10 years — Javi Gracia at Watford in 2019 and Nuno Espirito Santo at Nottingham Forest last year.
Who are the managers under pressure at Fulham and Manchester United?
Alvaro Arbeloa is under pressure at Fulham after no wins in four league games, while Michael Carrick is under scrutiny at Manchester United following the 3-2 EFL Cup defeat to Brighton.
Related Articles
Filed under: Manager News | LA Premier League Home
