The Punishment Is Not the Crime—It's the Cover-Up

Everton have been deducted 10 points for breaching the Premier League's profitability and sustainability rules. The righteous click their tongues, but they miss the point entirely. The crime was not overspending; the crime was not winning the financial arms race that the Premier League itself designed.

The Myth of Self-Sustainability

The league preaches self-sustainability while its biggest clubs rack up debts that would bankrupt sovereign nations. Manchester United owe £969 million in gross debt. Chelsea have spent over £1 billion since Todd Boehly's takeover—and still finished 12th. Yet it is Everton, who spent a modest £400 million over four years, that earns the first major punishment. The rules do not enforce financial discipline; they protect incumbents.

The Double Standards of the Elite

The litany of hypocrisy is staggering. Consider:

  • Manchester City faced 115 charges for financial breaches dating back to 2009—still unpunished, still winning titles.
  • Chelsea under Roman Abramovich spent unchecked for two decades, no points deduction ever materialised.
  • Arsenal and Liverpool both posted pre-tax losses exceeding £100 million in 2020-21—no action taken.
The only common thread? The clubs punished are those without a sugar daddy or a state-backed sovereign wealth fund. Everton's owner Farhad Moshiri is a businessman, not a prince. His £450 million investment looks reckless only because he cannot turn losses into trophies.

But What About the Rules?

Defenders of the system argue that rules exist to be followed. Indeed, Everton breached the threshold—£105 million in losses over three years. But the rulebook was written by the cartel. The maximum penalty is a deduction of points for PSR breaches; there is no cap on commercial manipulation, inflated sponsorships, or creative accounting. When Manchester City's Etihad deal was questioned, the Premier League changed the rule—in 2021, new associated party transaction rules were introduced. Too late for the rest.

The Inevitable Endgame

Here is a prediction that can be proved right or wrong: within three years, the Premier League will scrap PSR entirely in favour of a squad cost ratio resembling UEFA's. The current system is untenable. The next club to face a points deduction will be either a newly promoted side or another would-be disruptor—not a member of the Big Six. When Leicester City, Aston Villa, or Brighton eventually breach, the punishment will be swift. But for clubs like Manchester City, Chelsea, or Newcastle United, the rules will be rewritten. The deduction at Goodison Park is not justice—it is a warning. And it will be ignored by those who matter.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home