Alternative Premier League Team of the Season: The Unsung Heroes of 2025/26

The official Premier League Team of the Season often rewards the most famous names. But what about the players who quietly delivered week after week? Here is our alternative XI—those who narrowly missed the cut but deserve their moment in the spotlight.

Goalkeeper: Bernd Leno (Fulham)

Fulham’s resurgence has been built on a solid defensive foundation. Leno kept 12 clean sheets, the third-most in the league, and his save percentage of 75.2% was among the best. Without his consistency, Marco Silva’s side would not have finished in the top half.

Defenders: Kieran Trippier (Newcastle), Marc Guéhi (Crystal Palace), Max Kilman (West Ham), Antonee Robinson (Fulham)

Trippier continued to be Newcastle’s creative hub from right-back, with nine assists and 37 key passes. Guéhi’s composed defending earned him a place in England’s Euro 2028 squad. Kilman anchored West Ham’s backline, making 132 clearances and 64 interceptions. Robinson’s overlapping runs and defensive discipline made him one of the league’s most improved left-backs.

Midfielders: Bruno Guimarães (Newcastle), João Palhinha (Fulham), Eberechi Eze (Crystal Palace)

Guimarães dictated play from deep, completing 1,890 passes with an 87.3% accuracy. Palhinha won 152 tackles, the most in the division. Eze scored eight goals and created 10 assists, weaving through defences with 64 successful dribbles. Their blend of steel and silk would enhance any side.

Forwards: Ollie Watkins (Aston Villa), Alexander Isak (Newcastle), Bryan Mbeumo (Brentford)

Watkins netted 16 league goals, including crucial strikes in Villa’s Champions League chase. Isak’s 14 goals and six assists made him Newcastle’s top scorer despite injury interruptions. Mbeumo stepped up after Ivan Toney’s transfer, scoring 12 and assisting eight, keeping Brentford competitive.

Why These Players Matter

This alternative XI reflects the depth of talent that often goes unnoticed. With 12 different clubs represented, it highlights how the Premier League’s strength is spread beyond the traditional top six.

  • Tactical flexibility: Each player offers unique skills—Palhinha’s ball-winning, Trippier’s set-piece delivery, Eze’s creativity—that could fit multiple systems.
  • Fantasy Premier League impact: Combined, these players would cost approximately £95 million in FPL, with Isak (£9.0m) and Watkins (£8.5m) providing high value.
  • Transfer value: Several are entering their prime, with estimated market values rising: Guéhi (£50m), Isak (£80m), and Guimarães (£70m).

What This Means for Next Season

Clubs will be desperate to retain these stars. Newcastle must secure Isak and Guimarães to push for a top-four finish. Fulham’s success depends on keeping Leno and Palhinha. Crystal Palace and Brentford will rely on Eze and Mbeumo to lead their attacks. If any of them move in the summer, expect record fees and immediate impact at their new clubs.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home