Manchester City see second offer for Anderson rejected

Nottingham Forest have turned down a second bid from Manchester City for midfielder Elliot Anderson, with the 22-year-old reportedly favouring a switch to the Etihad Stadium over Manchester United, according to sources familiar with the talks.

Background and context

Anderson joined Forest from Newcastle United in July 2023 for £15 million, signing a five-year contract. He made 22 Premier League appearances last season, scoring two goals and providing three assists, primarily operating as a central midfielder but capable of playing on the left flank. Forest have been keen to retain the Scotland Under-21 international, but their financial situation may force a sale before the June 30 accounting deadline to comply with Profitability and Sustainability Rules. The club are under pressure to generate around £30 million in pure profit from player sales before the year-end accounting period.

City have already bolstered their midfield this window with the addition of Matheus Nunes from Wolverhampton Wanderers, but manager Pep Guardiola remains keen to add depth in central areas following Ilkay Gundogan's departure to Barcelona. The first offer for Anderson is understood to have been in the region of £25 million, with this latest bid believed to be closer to £30 million. Forest value Anderson at around £35 million, partly due to the premium on homegrown talent in the Premier League.

Impact and analysis

Anderson's preference for City over United is significant given the recent rivalry between the two Manchester clubs. His technical profile, combative style and ability to carry the ball through midfield make him a strong fit for Guardiola's system, which demands high pressing and quick transitions. For Forest, losing a key midfielder would be a blow, but the potential profit — considering his £15 million acquisition cost — could help them avoid a points deduction. Forest were docked four points last season for breaching financial rules, making compliance a top priority.

  • Anderson could provide cover for Kevin De Bruyne and Bernardo Silva, offering a more physical presence in the engine room.
  • Forest would need to reinvest quickly if Anderson leaves, with targets likely in the £10-15 million range to maximise profit.
  • United remain interested but may pivot to other midfield targets, such as Sofyan Amrabat, if a deal for Anderson falls through.

What's next

Forest are expected to hold out for a fee closer to their valuation, with City considering a third offer. Newcastle United, who inserted a sell-on clause in Anderson's contract, would receive a percentage of any fee, potentially complicating negotiations. The transfer window closes on September 1, but City may accelerate their pursuit to secure Anderson early. If the deal collapses, United could re-enter the race, but Anderson's apparent preference gives City a significant advantage.

Filed under: Transfer News | LA Premier League Home