Carragher: Elite manager would have turned Liverpool around

Jamie Carragher believes an elite manager would have addressed Liverpool's issues last season, following the shock sacking of Arne Slot. The former Liverpool defender expressed surprise at the decision but pointed to deeper problems at the club.

Context and background

Liverpool's 2025-26 campaign fell short of expectations, leading to Slot's dismissal after just one season in charge. Carragher, speaking on Sky Sports, argued that a top-tier manager could have rectified the team's flaws earlier, highlighting a lack of tactical flexibility and poor squad management.

The Reds finished fifth in the Premier League, missing Champions League qualification. Injuries to key players and inconsistent form plagued their season, but Carragher insisted an elite coach would have navigated these challenges better.

Impact and analysis

The sacking has left Liverpool searching for a new manager, with several names linked to the role. Carragher's comments add pressure on the board to appoint a proven winner. The club's style of play under Slot was criticised for being predictable, and an elite manager could bring the tactical nous required to compete with Manchester City and Arsenal.

  • Liverpool's possession stats dropped by 8% compared to the previous season.
  • They registered 10 fewer goals from set pieces than in 2024-25.
  • The club's pressing intensity declined, leading to more defensive errors.

Carragher noted that elite managers like Pep Guardiola or Jurgen Klopp (in his prime) would have adapted the system to suit the squad. Missing out on the Champions League also affects transfer market appeal and revenue.

What's next for Liverpool

The club must appoint a new manager quickly to salvage next season. Targets include former Liverpool midfielder Xabi Alonso and Sporting's Ruben Amorim. The board faces scrutiny to ensure the next appointment can restore the club to elite status. Carragher's warning serves as a stark reminder that time is of the essence.

Filed under: Opinion | LA Premier League Home