The Premier League's Penalty Killers: Goalkeepers Who Have Saved the Most Spots
Discover which Premier League shot-stoppers have the best records from 12 yards, including stats, techniques, and historic saves.
In the pressure-cooker environment of the Premier League, few moments are as decisive—or as nerve-wracking—as a penalty kick. For the taker, it's a golden opportunity to score. For the goalkeeper, it's a test of nerve, reflexes, and psychology. Over the years, some 'keepers have built reputations as penalty specialists, with stats that terrify even the most confident forwards.
Top 5 Premier League Goalkeepers with Most Penalty Saves (All-Time)
- Mark Schwarzer – 6 saves: The Australian legend, who played for Middlesbrough, Fulham, and Chelsea, leads the list with six penalty saves in the Premier League. His towering frame and calm demeanor made him a formidable barrier.
- Brad Friedel – 6 saves: The American shot-stopper, known for his longevity and consistency, matched Schwarzer's record while playing for Blackburn, Aston Villa, and Tottenham. His reading of the striker's run-up was second to none.
- Tim Howard – 5 saves: Another American star, Howard made his mark at Everton and Manchester United. His agility and powerful presence helped him deny five penalties in the Premier League.
- Heurelho Gomes – 5 saves: The Brazilian had a reputation for being eccentric, but his penalty-saving ability was top-notch. Playing for Tottenham and Watford, Gomes saved five penalties in the division.
- Jussi Jääskeläinen – 5 saves: The Finnish giant was a hero for Bolton Wanderers and later West Ham. His positioning and anticipation earned him a spot on this elite list.
Modern Specialists: The Current Crop
Many current Premier League goalkeepers are making their mark from 12 yards. Alisson Becker (Liverpool) has saved four penalties, while Ederson (Manchester City) has three. Both rely on intense study of opponents' habits. Kasper Schmeichel (Leicester) has five penalty saves, following in his father's footsteps. Jordan Pickford (Everton) has saved four, often using his fiery temperament to intimidate takers.
What Makes a Penalty-Saving Goalkeeper?
It's not just luck. Top penalty savers combine physical attributes (height, reach, quick reflexes) with mental strength and preparation. Many study footage of opponents to spot tendencies—like a glance at the corner before shooting or a delayed run-up. Others rely on instinct and positioning. The best also have a long reach, allowing them to cover more of the goal.
The Pressure of Saving a Penalty
Saving a penalty can shift the momentum of a match instantly. It energizes the team and the crowd, often leading to a victory. For goalkeepers, it's a moment of individual glory in a team sport. The psychological impact on the taker can be lasting—some strikers have avoided penalties after being denied by a particular 'keeper.
In the ever-evolving Premier League, the battle between penalty taker and goalkeeper continues. While strikers practice placement and power, goalkeepers study and refine their techniques. The list of penalty-saving heroes grows each season, and fans will always celebrate the moment their 'keeper becomes a hero from 12 yards.